Atty. Tamano Statement on Ancestral Domain


There is no one more interested in peace in Mindanao than I. I am a true son of Mindanao and my family, specifically my late father, Mamintal Tamano, has been in the forefront of finding a just settlement to the Mindanao conflict. On a purely personal level, I am very happy that the ancestral rights of the Bangsamoro people are recognized in the MOA on Ancestral Domain. However, the document – and the process undertaken by the Government – are constitutionally flawed and, in the long run, will prove harmful to the peace process.

It is unfortunate for both Muslims and Christians in the Philippines that GMA has polluted the Peace Process by negotiating in bad faith, promising the MILF things she cannot deliver, using the process as a backdoor to amending the Constitution, and, ultimately, setting the conditions for escalating the conflict in Mindanao.

As shown by the MOA on Ancestral Domain between the GMA Administration and the MILF, particularly Section 3 on Concepts and Principles, which states that ancestral domain does not form part of the Philippines’ public domain, GMA has effectively ceded part of the territory of the Philippines to the MILF. Obviously, GMA is not empowered to give up any part of our country to any group, only the Filipino people can do that in their sovereign capacity and only via amending the Constitution.

As others have pointed out, GMA, being a highly unpopular President, does not have the social capital to convince Filipinos to cede their territory, even for something as important as peace in Mindanao. So when the inevitable occurs and the Government fails to deliver the on its promise to the MILF, the rebels will have a clear casus belli or a justification for acts of war.

There will be some who will argue that the MOA is constitutional in light of the Indigenous People Rights Act (IPRA). However, the IPRA underwent vigorous debate both in Congress and, later, in the Supreme Court. For the issue of ancestral domain rights for the proposed Bangsamoro Juridical Entity (BJE), there has been no public debate. In fact, the terms of the agreement were kept secret and hidden in the shadows away from public scrutiny.

It is the aspect of transparency and opening this issue to public debate and discussion that is sorely missing in this entire process. While, certainly, we must all seek peace in Mindanao, it should be done in an open manner and with justice to all. In fact, perhaps through the public debates it may be shown that my views on this issue are entirely wrong and that the government has dealt in good faith. I would actually be happy with that result.

However, until the Filipino people are involved in a broad-based discussion on this issue that will have a profound effect on our country’s future, we should approach this agreement – and the government’s motives – with caution.

As a final note, there may be some who will misconstrue my words and say that I am against recognizing the ancestral rights of Moros. That is untrue. Let me be clear – the aspiration for justice and peace for Moros, which includes issues on ancestral domain, integration, and even reparations for Moros, is something that I have always advocated. But we must see things in the long term and find the solutions to the conflict in a manner that is transparent, constitutional, and inclusive.



  1. ekdd said,

    August 5, 2008 at 6:19 am

    Thank you sir for your statement. I have been waiting for this.

  2. jr said,

    August 5, 2008 at 10:05 am

    sir what is the meaning of young turks nd the main missin vission po keep up or the good work to our country mabuhay p[o godbls sa inyo po lahat…..

  3. liling magtolis briones said,

    August 5, 2008 at 2:23 pm

    Dear Adel,

    Congratulations for stating so clearly your position on the aborted MOA of the government with the MILF. When I read the basic provisions of the agreement, I wondered how the government could have the gall to promise the MILF what it cannot give in the first place. Surely, the government knew that a constitutional amendment was necessary. Surely, the government knew that it cannot guarantee to deliver such a constitutional amendment. It is the people who will make that decision.

    For centuries, the Moros have been consistently shortchanged. It is too dangerous for this government to gift them with lavish promises which are not in its power to give. It is not fair to Moros and Christians alike. All of us will suffer the consequences of such blatant trickery.

    Her trust ratings say it all. We cannot trust this government to make empty promises to fellow Filipinos who have suffered from indifference and neglect for so long. It is so unfair to the Moros. It is so unfair to the Christians as well.

    Prof. Liling Magtolis Briones

  4. wehavenoname said,

    August 6, 2008 at 3:43 am

    Dear JR,

    Thank you for your comment. I think the Visayan Daily Star newspaper editorial that I posted today captures perfectly what the Young Turks stand for. Although we belong to different factions of the Opposition and our elders might run for President in 2010, we are showing that we can work together. We are going around the country in our campus tours to feel the pulse of the young and talk to them. We have seen and heard a lot of longing for change, and also a lack of hope from the young. This should not be the case.

    Youth is the best time of our lives. It should be filled with hope and the commitment that we can change things. After all, the point of all learning is to help change the world. — Danton

  5. Leon said,

    August 9, 2008 at 9:29 am

    In the light of the circumstances, peace process is inevitable. You(Arroyo Administration) simply can’t impose peace without consulting the people actually affected by your actions. I would like to challenge those people (the families of Esperon, Dureza and all those hypocrites in the government to live in the war torn areas of mindanaoo who have viewed that through this MOA we will achieve peaceful life here in the affected areas of Mindanao. I agree with your view sir, that the process the government have undertaken was somewhat a tactic to pursue thier hidden agenda.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: